Can Jump Height Lie?
Sport science has a lot of new toys. Force plates, high-speed cameras and apps can now break a single jump or sprint into dozens of numbers: peak force, contraction time, reactive strength index, braking impulse and more.
That detail can be useful. But a trend has grown, especially on social media, of treating these extra numbers as more important than the result itself. One recent paper was titled "Jump height lies." Another argued that jump height is "a poor indicator" of leg power.
If you're a coach, a parent or an athlete, that's confusing. If jump height can't be trusted, what's the point of testing it?
What the New Research Says.
In November 2026, four sport scientists, Irineu Loturco, Daniel Boullosa, Fábio Nakamura and Øyvind Sandbakk, published a commentary called When Proxies Overshadow Actual Performance. Their message is simple: the result comes first.
- Height and time can't lie. Height, distance and time are base measurements in physics. Measured with a reliable tool and a consistent method, they record exactly what happened.
- A higher jump means more power. For the same athlete, doing the same jump, at a similar body weight, a higher jump can only come from leaving the ground faster. That takes more push into the ground relative to body weight, which is relative power. Jump height adds all of that up into one number.
- The detail explains, it doesn't judge. Force-time numbers can show how an athlete jumped or why a result changed. They're most useful when the question is fatigue, rehab or technique. They shouldn't replace the result.
- A different technique isn't a worse one. If an athlete jumps higher or runs faster, they've improved, even if some of the detailed numbers moved in a direction that looks "bad".
- Keep it simple where you can. The authors warn against selling expensive, complex technology as essential when simple, valid tests already answer the question.
The same logic applies to sprinting. A sprint time is the end product of everything an athlete did: every push, every ground contact, every step.
Loturco I, Boullosa D, Nakamura FY, Sandbakk Ø. When proxies overshadow actual performance: reaffirming first principles in applied sport science. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 2026. doi:10.1123/ijspp.2026-0380
Coach the mechanism. Measure the outcome.
Why We Use the Abalakov Jump.
There are two common ways to test a vertical jump. On force plates, the standard is usually a countermovement jump with hands on hips. At Power2ADAPT, we use the Abalakov jump: the same countermovement, with a free arm swing.
Takes the arms out of the jump. More controlled and repeatable, which suits force plates and isolating what the legs are doing.
Arm swing allowed. The whole body works together, the way athletes actually jump in their sport.
My reasoning is transfer to real play. No footballer contests a mark, no netballer takes a rebound and no basketballer goes up for a block with their hands on their hips. In sport, the arms drive the jump. Coordinating the arm swing with the leg drive is part of the skill, so it's part of what we want to measure.
The hands-on-hips jump has a real place. It's more controlled and more repeatable, and it's the better choice when the goal is to analyse the legs in detail on a force plate. But the model I coach is "how does it transfer?" For the athletes I work with, the Abalakov jump answers that question more directly.
There's a practical reason too. All of our historical data uses the Abalakov jump, so every new result can be compared with what came before. As the research above points out, jump heights can only be compared when the jump type is the same. An Abalakov score and a hands-on-hips score are not interchangeable.
Measure What Transfers.
Coach the mechanism, measure the outcome
In our sprint mechanics work, we use hurdles, cones and wickets in the warm-up to shape how athletes apply force to the ground. Ground contact and horizontal push explain why an athlete gets faster, but the timing gates give the verdict. A drill that looks neat but doesn't change the 20 m time hasn't done its job.
Standardise, or the numbers mean nothing
Same jump type, same start, same timing system and distances, same surface and ideally the same time of day. On outdoor tracks, note the wind and conditions.
Know what a real change looks like
Every test has natural variation. A few hundredths of a second can be noise. Look for changes bigger than that, and trends across several tests, before drawing conclusions.
Use the jump as a quick check-in
Jump height is sensitive enough to pick up neuromuscular fatigue. A few jumps mid-program can show whether an athlete is coping, with equipment you already have.
The Simple Numbers Are the Right Numbers.
Progress you can trust
You don't need a lab report full of charts to know if your child is improving. A faster sprint and a higher jump are real, meaningful progress.
Compare your child with themselves
Normative tables describe groups and can't account for growth and maturation. The most useful comparison is your child's own previous result.
Growth spurts change the picture
When a young athlete grows quickly, body weight, limb length and coordination all change. A jump that holds steady while your child gains height and weight can still mean they're getting more powerful.
Small dips are normal
Results can stall or dip for a few days as training fatigue builds, then bounce back higher after recovery. One flat test isn't a step backwards.
Be wary of the hype
If someone says only expensive technology can show whether your child is improving, ask what question the extra numbers actually answer. Often, height and time already answer it.
Faster Is Faster.
Your number is yours
Your 20 m time and your jump height are honest measures of what you can do right now. Use them as your benchmark, not someone else's.
The clock is the judge
If your time drops, you got faster. Your running might look a bit different as you grow or as we change your technique. That's fine.
Help the test be fair
Warm up properly, turn up fed, hydrated and rested, and wear shoes with good grip. Give every attempt full effort.
Expect ups and downs
Big gains often come early, then progress slows. Keep showing up: consistency is what moves the numbers over a season.
The clock is the judge. Consistency moves the numbers.
Simple Tests. Reliable Tools.
Our testing is built on direct outcomes, measured with electronic timing gates and a jump mat, and done the same way every time.
We test at three points: a baseline to see where an athlete starts, a check-in to see how they're coping and adapting, and a result to show the improvement they've earned.
When the question goes deeper, such as returning from injury, managing fatigue or understanding movement strategy, our Elite testing adds detailed force and tissue analysis with our expert partners. That's the right tool for those questions. For tracking speed and power, height and time lead the way.
Both Views Can Be True.
This is an active debate, and it's worth knowing both sides. The commentary is an expert opinion piece, not a new study. Researchers on the other side, including Morin and colleagues and Marques, Buchheit and colleagues, argue that force-time metrics can reveal fatigue or changes that jump height alone can miss, particularly in elite athletes with heavy training and match loads.
Detailed metrics help answer "why" questions in the right setting. For coaches, parents and young athletes tracking speed and power, the result is still the best place to start.
Five Questions to Ask.
- What question are we actually trying to answer with this test?
- Was the test done the same way as last time?
- Is this change bigger than normal day-to-day variation?
- Has the athlete grown or changed weight since the last test?
- If the result improved, does it matter that the technique looks different?
Read more: Faster Off the Mark (what we train and why we test) and Why Sprint Mechanics Matter at Every Level (how we coach it).